| 2008 |
Mike Wilpolt |
Cleveland Gladiators |
| 2007 |
Doug Plank |
Georgia Force |
| 2006 |
Will McClay |
Dallas Desperados |
| 2005 |
Doug Plank |
Georgia Force |
| 2004 |
Mike Neu |
New Orleans VooDoo |
| 2003 |
Todd Shell |
New York Dragons |
| 2002 |
Darren Arbet |
San Jose SaberCats |
| 2001 |
Michael Trigg |
Grand Rapids Rampage |
| 2000 |
Darren Arbet |
San Jose SaberCats |
| 1999 |
Mike Dailey |
Albany Firebirds |
| 1998 |
Tim Marcum |
Tampa Bay Storm |
| 1997 |
Eddie Khayat |
Nashville Kats |
| 1996 |
John Gregory |
Iowa Barnstormers |
| 1995 |
John Gregory |
Iowa Barnstormers |
| 1994 |
Perry Moss |
Orlando Predators |
| 1993 |
Danny White |
Arizona Rattlers |
| 1992 |
Perry Moss |
Orlando Predators |
| 1991 |
Fran Curci |
Tampa Bay Storm |
| 1990 |
Ernie Stautner |
Dallas Texans |
| 1989 |
Babe Parilli |
Denver Dynamite |
| 1988 |
Perry Moss |
Chicago Bruisers |
| 1987 |
Tim Marcum |
Denver Dynamite |
|