| New York Yankees (20-16) at Toronto Blue Jays (19-18) |
| Game One |
Wednesday, May 16th, 7:07 p.m. |
| Game Two |
Thursday, May 17th, 7:07 p.m. |
| Records |
| 2012 Head-to-Head Record |
First meeting |
| 2011 Head-to-Head Record |
New York 11-7 (7-2 at NY; 4-5 at Tor) |
| 2010 Head-to-Head Record |
Toronto 10-8 (4-5 at NY; 6-3 at Tor) |
| 2009 Head-to-Head Record |
New York 12-6 (6-3 at NY; 6-3 at Tor) |
| Home Record |
New York 11-8; Toronto 8-9 |
| Away Record |
New York 9-8; Toronto 11-9 |
| Current Streak |
New York (L1); Toronto (L3) |
| Record vs. Eastern Division |
New York 9-7; Toronto 4-10 |
| 2011 Meetings |
| 4/19 - Toronto, 6-5 (10) (at Tor - WP: Rauch; LP: Nova) |
| 4/20 - New York, 6-2 (at Tor - WP: Colon; LP: Cecil) |
| 4/29 - Toronto, 5-3 (at NY - WP: R.Romero; LP: F.Garcia) |
| 4/30 - New York, 5-4 (at NY - WP: AJ.Burnett; LP: Drabek) |
| 5/01 - New York, 5-2 (at NY - WP: Nova; LP: Litsch) |
| 5/23 - Toronto, 7-3 (at NY - WP: C.Villanueva; LP: Colon) |
| 5/24 - New York, 5-4 (at NY - WP: Sabathia; LP: Francisco) |
| 5/25 - New York, 7-3 (at NY - WP: F.Garcia; LP: J-J.Reyes) |
| 7/14 - Toronto, 16-7 (at Tor - WP: J-J.Reyes; LP: Colon) |
| 7/15 - Toronto, 7-1 (at Tor - WP: Morrow; LP: F.Garcia) |
| 7/16 - New York, 4-1 (at Tor - WP: Sabathia; LP: R.Romero) |
| 7/17 - New York, 7-2 (at Tor - WP: P.Hughes; LP: C.Villanueva) |
| 9/02 - New York, 3-2 (at NY - WP: Nova; LP: Morrow) |
| 9/03 - New York, 6-4 (at NY - WP: Logan; LP: R.Romero) |
| 9/04 - New York, 9-3 (at NY - WP: Sabathia; LP: Cecil) |
| 9/16 - Toronto, 5-4 (at Tor - WP: Janssen; LP: Logan) |
| 9/17 - New York, 7-6 (at Tor - WP: Laffey; LP: Villanueva) |
| 9/18 - Toronto, 3-0 (at Tor - WP: Morrow; LP: F.Garcia) |
| 2010 Meetings |
| 6/04 - Toronto, 6-1 (at Tor - WP: Cecil; LP: AJ.Burnett) |
| 6/05 - Toronto, 3-2 (14) (at Tor - WP: Janssen; LP: Gaudin) |
| 6/06 - New York, 4-3 (at Tor - WP: J.Vazquez; LP: S.Downs) |
| 7/02 - Toronto, 6-1 (11) (at NY - WP: Frasor; LP: D.Robertson) |
| 7/03 - New York, 11-3 (at NY - WP: Pettitte; LP: R.Romero) |
| 7/04 - New York, 7-6 (10) (at NY - WP: D.Robertson; LP: Purcey) |
| 8/02 - Toronto, 8-6 (at NY - WP: Morrow; LP: AJ.Burnett) |
| 8/03 - Toronto, 8-2 (at NY - WP: R.Romero; LP: Moseley) |
| 8/04 - New York, 5-1 (at NY - WP: P.Hughes; LP: Marcum) |
| 8/23 - Toronto, 3-2 (at Tor - WP: S.Downs; LP: D.Robertson) |
| 8/24 - New York, 11-5 (at Tor - WP: Moseley; LP: Rzepczynski) |
| 8/25 - Toronto, 6-3 (at Tor - WP: Cecil; LP: P.Hughes) |
| 9/03 - New York, 7-3 (at NY - WP: K.Wood; LP: Morrow) |
| 9/04 - New York, 7-5 (at NY - WP: Chamberlain; LP: Frasor) |
| 9/05 - Toronto, 7-3 (at NY - WP: Cecil; LP: P.Hughes) |
| 9/27 - Toronto, 7-5 (at Tor - WP: Rzepczynski; LP: AJ.Burnett) |
| 9/28 - New York, 6-1 (at Tor - WP: Sabathia; LP: Drabek) |
| 9/29 - Toronto, 8-4 (at Tor - WP: Cecil; LP: J.Vazquez) |
| 2009 Meetings |
| 5/12 - Toronto, 5-1 (at Tor - WP: Halladay; LP: AJ.Burnett) |
| 5/13 - New York, 8-2 (at Tor - WP: Pettitte; LP: Richmond) |
| 5/14 - New York, 3-2 (at Tor - WP: Sabathia; LP: Carlson) |
| 7/03 - New York, 4-2 (at NY - WP: AJ.Burnett; LP: Tallet) |
| 7/04 - New York, 6-5 (12) (at NY - WP: Tomko; LP: Camp) |
| 7/05 - New York, 10-8 (at NY - WP: Albaladejo; LP: Ryan) |
| 7/06 - Toronto, 7-6 (at NY - WP: R.Romero; LP: Pettitte) |
| 8/04 - New York, 5-3 (at Tor - WP: Pettitte; LP: Halladay) |
| 8/05 - New York, 8-4 (at Tor - WP: Aceves; LP: Rzepczynski) |
| 8/10 - Toronto, 5-4 (at NY - WP: Camp; LP: Mitre) |
| 8/11 - New York, 7-5 (at NY - WP: D.Robertson; LP: Carlson) |
| 8/12 - New York, 4-3 (11) (at NY - WP: Gaudin; LP: Camp) |
| 9/03 - New York, 10-5 (at Tor - WP: Aceves; LP: R.Romero) |
| 9/04 - Toronto, 6-0 (at Tor - WP: Halladay; LP: Chamberlain) |
| 9/05 - New York, 6-4 (at Tor - WP: Pettitte; LP: Cecil) |
| 9/06 - Toronto, 14-8 (at Tor - WP: Tallet; LP: Mitre) |
| 9/15 - Toronto, 10-4 (at NY - WP: Halladay; LP: Mitre) |
| 9/16 - New York, 5-4 (at NY - WP: Ma.Rivera; LP: Frasor) |
| New York last five games |
Toronto last five games |
| 5/11 - W vs. Seattle, 6-2 |
5/11 - L at Minnesota, 6-7 |
| 5/12 - W vs. Seattle, 6-2 |
5/12 - W at Minnesota, 2-1 |
| 5/13 - L vs. Seattle, 2-6 |
5/13 - L at Minnesota, 3-4 |
| 5/14 - W at Baltimore, 8-5 |
5/14 - L vs. Tampa Bay, 1-7 |
| 5/15 - L at Baltimore, 2-5 |
5/15 - L vs. Tampa Bay, 3-4 |