| 1st Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 13:37 | NY Rangers | NY Rangers Goal - Dan Girardi, from Marian Gaborik and Artem Anisimov at 6:23. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| 4:42 | Toronto | Joffrey Lupul - 2 minutes for hi-sticking |
| 4:42 | NY Rangers | Ryan Callahan - 2 minutes for roughing |
| 13:18 | NY Rangers | Brandon Prust - 2 minutes for interference |
| 13:28 | Toronto | Tim Connolly - 2 minutes for clipping |
| 14:03 | Toronto | Carl Gunnarsson - 2 minutes for holding |
| 15:17 | NY Rangers | Derek Stepan - 2 minutes for hi-sticking |
| |
| 2nd Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 18:40 | Toronto | Toronto Goal - Matthew Lombardi (2), from Tyler Bozak and Carl Gunnarsson at 1:20. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| 1:31 | Toronto | Mike Brown - 5 minutes for fighting (maj) |
| 1:31 | NY Rangers | Kris Newbury - 5 minutes for fighting (maj) |
| 8:21 | Toronto | Matt Frattin - 2 minutes for interference on goalkeeper |
| |
| 3rd Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 17:49 | Toronto | Toronto Goal - Joffrey Lupul (5), from Jake Gardiner and Phil Kessel at 2:11. |
| 13:27 | Toronto | Toronto Goal - Clarke MacArthur, from Mike Komisarek at 6:33. |
| 6:06 | Toronto | Toronto Goal - Mike Brown, from John-Michael Liles at 13:54. |
| 4:34 | NY Rangers | NY Rangers Goal - Michael Del Zotto, unassisted at 15:26. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| 7:45 | NY Rangers | Brad Richards - 2 minutes for slashing |
| 15:58 | NY Rangers | Brandon Dubinsky - 2 minutes for unsportsmanlike conduct |
