| Status | Score | | Thursday, October 18, 2012 |
| Final | NC CENTRAL | 37 | Hampton | 20 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Saturday, October 20, 2012 |
| Final | DUQUESNE | 35 | Sacred Heart | 3 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final(OT) | JACKSONVILLE ST | 31 | Tennessee St | 28 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (13) New Hampshire | 28 | MAINE | 21 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | ROBERT MORRIS | 37 | Cent Conn St | 31 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (21) Wagner | 31 | ST FRANCIS-PA | 24 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | YALE | 27 | Penn | 13 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | BROWN | 21 | Cornell | 14 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (16) LEHIGH | 42 | Bucknell | 19 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (25) COLGATE | 57 | Georgetown | 36 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | DAYTON | 45 | Valparaiso | 0 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | HOWARD | 21 | Morgan State | 20 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | San Diego | 24 | JACKSONVILLE | 7 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | LAFAYETTE | 30 | Holy Cross | 13 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | Bryant | 27 | MONMOUTH | 24 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | PRINCETON | 39 | Harvard | 34 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | CHAR SOUTHERN | 31 | Presbyterian | 21 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | Dartmouth | 21 | COLUMBIA | 16 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | DELAWARE STATE | 24 | NC A&T | 0 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (3) Ga Southern | 38 | FURMAN | 17 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (24) Coastal Carolina | 34 | VA MILITARY | 7 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final(OT) | DRAKE | 34 | Marist | 27 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | Missouri State | 24 | (8) ILLINOIS STATE | 17 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | SAVANNAH STATE | 42 | Edward Waters | 35 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | Tenn-Martin | 27 | SE MISSOURI ST | 17 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | ELON | 42 | Western Carolina | 31 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | GRAMBLING ST | 22 | VA-Lynchburg | 7 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | Weber State | 24 | SOUTHERN UTAH | 22 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (7) Wofford | 38 | (9) APPALACHIAN ST | 28 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | DELAWARE | 47 | Rhode Island | 24 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (15) Villanova | 49 | GEORGIA STATE | 24 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | LIBERTY | 21 | Concord | 13 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | NORTH DAKOTA | 40 | Montana | 34 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | PRAIRIE VIEW | 52 | Alcorn State | 37 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (18) RICHMOND | 35 | (19) James Madison | 29 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | NORTHERN COLORADO | 52 | Idaho State | 14 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (22) BETHUNE-COOKMAN | 48 | Norfolk State | 3 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final(2nd OT) | JACKSON STATE | 14 | Miss Valley St | 7 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | STEPHEN F AUSTIN | 44 | Nicholls | 10 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (11) STONY BROOK | 41 | Gardner-Webb | 10 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | Southern Ill | 38 | YOUNGSTOWN ST | 21 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | NORTHERN IOWA | 27 | (14) South Dakota St | 6 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | BUTLER | 39 | Morehead State | 35 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | Davidson | 28 | CAMPBELL | 21 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | CHATTANOOGA | 20 | Samford | 13 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final(OT) | SC State | 27 | FLORIDA A&M | 20 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (10) CENTRAL ARKANSAS | 24 | Lamar | 14 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (1) North Dakota St | 54 | SOUTH DAKOTA | 0 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | Ark-Pine Bluff | 50 | SOUTHERN U | 21 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (6) Old Dominion | 31 | (17) TOWSON | 20 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | Indiana State | 23 | WESTERN ILL | 7 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (4) EASTERN WASH | 31 | Sacramento St | 28 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (20) NORTHERN ARIZ | 21 | UC Davis | 7 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (2) SAM HOUSTON ST | 45 | McNeese State | 10 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (23) Eastern Ky | 42 | TENN TECH | 28 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
| Final | (12) CAL POLY | 37 | Portland State | 25 | Preview | Log | Wrap | Box |
