| 1st Period |
| Pittsburgh Goal - James Neal (16), from Matt Niskanen and Kris Letang at :36. 19:24 Remaining. |
| Toronto Power-Play Goal - James van Riemsdyk (14), from Phil Kessel and Dion Phaneuf at 7:14. 12:46 Remaining. |
| Pittsburgh Goal - Sidney Crosby (12), from Kris Letang and Beau Bennett at 14:31. 5:29 Remaining. |
| Pittsburgh Goal - Paul Martin (5), from James Neal and Evgeni Malkin at 15:21. 4:39 Remaining. |
| 2nd Period |
| Toronto Power-Play Goal - Cody Franson (2), from Phil Kessel and Dion Phaneuf at 10:12. 9:48 Remaining. |
| Pittsburgh Goal - Pascal Dupuis (9), from Paul Martin and Brooks Orpik at 13:01. 6:59 Remaining. |
| Toronto Goal - Clarke MacArthur (7), from Dion Phaneuf and Matt Frattin at 14:01. 5:59 Remaining. |
| 3rd Period |
| Toronto Goal - Phil Kessel (7), from Mark Fraser and Clarke MacArthur at 15:40. 4:20 Remaining. |
| Overtime |
| No Scoring |
