| 1st Period |
| NY Rangers Goal - Dan Girardi, from Carl Hagelin and Rick Nash at 3:36. 16:24 Remaining. |
| NY Rangers Goal - Marian Gaborik (7), from Brad Richards and Ryan Callahan at 11:28. 8:32 Remaining. |
| 2nd Period |
| NY Islanders Goal - Colin McDonald (2), from Casey Cizikas at :29. 19:31 Remaining. |
| NY Islanders Goal - John Tavares (8), unassisted at 6:45. 13:15 Remaining. |
| NY Islanders Goal - Brad Boyes (4), from Lubomir Visnovsky and Brian Strait at 7:25. 12:35 Remaining. |
| NY Rangers Power-Play Goal - Carl Hagelin (5), from Marian Gaborik and Marc Staal at 11:14. 8:46 Remaining. |
| 3rd Period |
| No Scoring |
| No Scoring |
| Overtime |
| No Scoring |
