Saturday Night Surfing: Recalling Jolting Upsets, Appreciating Froch
Lyle Fitzsimmons

By Lyle Fitzsimmons,
Contributing Boxing Editor

Ocala, FL (Sports Network) - Against my better judgment, I looked at it again.

Even though every previous viewing -- whether in connection with an anniversary or not -- has prompted a subsequent hour or more of muttering and slack-jawed disbelief, I still lingered online after the close of Saturday night's Carl Froch-Glen Johnson fight to take yet another look.

And even though I'm up to about 1,000 viewings in what's now been 23 years and 24 hours since the in-ring version of D-Day, the result hasn't changed one friggin' bit.

No matter how strong and sound and superb Thomas Hearns looks through 2 1/2 rounds of his June 6, 1988, middleweight title defense against Iran Barkley, the right hand still arrives.

Carl Froch retained his WBC Super Middleweight title on Saturday night.
He still collapses to the floor when it lands. He still wills himself to stand one tick before the count reaches 10. And he's still far too unfit to continue when Richard Steele humanely intervenes with 21 seconds remaining in the third.

The guy was my favorite for 20-plus years. I saw all the big fights -- wins and losses -- he ever had.

I even had the chance to meet and interview him in a Detroit casino in 2005.

But no moment in those two-plus decades ever packed the "holy sh*t, did I really just see that?!?" wallop created by that 30-second stretch at the Hilton in Las Vegas.

I was lured into watching it again when the Internet feed of HBO's Chavez-Zbik fight went cold after five or so rounds last Saturday. I was still buzzing from Froch's performance via Sky Sports an hour earlier, and wasn't quite ready to either call it a night or reduce myself to Saturday Night Live wannabes or the smugness of Harvey Levin and his band of TMZ smart-asses.

As it turned out, it became something of a theme night.

First was Hearns-Barkley I. Then came Moorer-Foreman.

And ultimately, it devolved to Jones-Tarver II.

The three most stunning moments I've had in 30 or so years as a conscious boxing fan.

Transcendent upsets like Tyson-Douglas don't count quite the same to me, because by the time the 10th round arrived in Tokyo, the ultimate result was hardly in doubt...except to Don King and his minions.

For my money -- both in terms of underdogs winning and complete reversals of up-to-that-moment momentum -- nothing since 1980 tops the trio of Barkley, Foreman and Tarver.

* * * * * * * * * *

But it was a tough-to-watch night for reasons beyond just Hearns.

By the time 1 a.m. rolled around, while watching the Jones-Tarver rematch, I again remembered the last great round fought by my second-favorite fighter...and the one punch that did more to alter an all-time legacy than any other I can recall.

For the first three minutes of their second go-round at Mandalay Bay, the "Superman" from Pensacola was pecking, flurrying and doing all the other things that made him a convincing winner over Hall of Famers and traffic cops through 49 of his first 50 fights.

Then the left hand came. And history changed.

Before it landed...he's among the best fighters ever.

Since...he's the poster boy for hanging on too long.

And rightly or wrongly, every account of Jones' career from here forward will include as much space covering what he's done in the last dozen fights -- 5 wins, 7 losses (four by KO) -- as it does those first four dozen plus two.

To me, it's a shame. Because as cocky and off-putting as he could be at times, Roy always seemed a decent guy at heart. And whether you're a true believer in his list of opponents prior to 2004 or not, it's nonetheless clear he was nearly impossible to beat when operating at his highest level.

As he crossed his arms and looked out at the crowd before stepping through the ropes to get at Tarver, I wished I could make it all go away. And though I've never been one to encourage retirement when guys are still in the upper percentiles of the profession, I hope I don't see any more.

* * * * * * * * * *

In terms of live action, my Saturday highlight was the aforementioned Froch.

I'd seen footage of the brash Englishman before, but I had never watched him in real time and I felt pretty strongly that Johnson would retain enough of the quality -- even at a smaller size -- he'd long shown against bigger, better men at 175 pounds.

Needless to say, I was way off.

I came away impressed enough with Froch's ability to control the action from the outside, but far more so with the mettle he showed in taking Johnson's best shots and responding almost without fail immediately with momentum- changing counter flurries.

It not only altered the game on the scorecards, but played a role in sapping the resilience of the 42-year-old, who looked far more like a beaten man at the final bell than in any of his recent losses.

And while I haven't changed my stance that Andre Ward is the best fighter both in this tournament and in the weight class -- sorry, Lucien -- it occurs to me now that the cable TV finale between he and Froch will be a far better clash than I would have believed going in.

Not to mention the series of great fights now available between 168 and 175 with other names like Kelly Pavlik, Chad Dawson, Jean Pascal and Bernard Hopkins, at least some of which seem destined to wind up on Showtime.

Congrats, Mr. Hershman, you've got me for at least one more.

* * * * * * * * * *

This week's title-fight schedule:


IBO middleweight title - Kiev, Ukraine

Avtandil Khurtsidze (champion) vs. Dionisio Miranda (No. 31 contender) Khurtsidze (24-2-2, 14 KO): First title defense; Unbeaten in Ukraine (16-0, 9 KO) Miranda (21-6-2, 18 KO): First title fight; Three wins in seven fights since 2008 (3-4, 1 KO)

Fitzbitz says: "Hometown favorite stays unblemished on backyard turf." Khurtsidze by decision

WBO junior bantamweight title - Buenos Aires, Argentina

Omar Narvaez (champion) vs. William Urina (No. 14 contender) Narvaez (34-0-2, 19 KO): Third title defense; Held WBO title at 112 pounds (2002-09, 16 defenses) Urina (17-1, 14 KO): First title fight; Lost only fight outside Colombia (0-1, 0 KO)

Fitzbitz says: "Long-time flyweight king extends reign on next ladder rung." Narvaez by decision

Last week's picks: 2-1

Overall picks record: 302-106 (74.0 percent)

Lyle Fitzsimmons is a veteran sports columnist who's written professionally since 1988 and covered boxing since 1995. His work is published in print and posted online for clients in North America and Europe. Reach him at or follow him on Twitter.

Jabs, hooks or knockouts, Lyle Fitzsimmons can be reached at

Powered by The Sports Network.