| 1st Period |
| Pittsburgh Power-Play Goal - Evgeni Malkin, from Sidney Crosby and Kris Letang at 18:51. 1:09 Remaining. |
| 2nd Period |
| Toronto Goal - Clarke MacArthur, from Nazem Kadri and Nikolai Kulemin at 3:09. 16:51 Remaining. |
| Toronto Goal - James van Riemsdyk, from Nikolai Kulemin and Mikhail Grabovski at 6:48. 13:12 Remaining. |
| Pittsburgh Goal - Sidney Crosby, from Pascal Dupuis at 7:17. 12:43 Remaining. |
| Toronto Goal - James van Riemsdyk (2), unassisted at 14:34. 5:26 Remaining. |
| 3rd Period |
| Toronto Goal - Mikhail Grabovski, from Nikolai Kulemin and James van Riemsdyk at 5:18. 14:42 Remaining. |
| Toronto Power-Play Goal - Tyler Bozak (2), from Clarke MacArthur and Mike Kostka at 18:59. 1:01 Remaining. |
