| 1st Period |
| NY Islanders Goal - Josh Bailey, from Kyle Okposo and Andrew MacDonald at 3:34. 16:26 Remaining. |
| Toronto Goal - Nazem Kadri (6), from Mark Fraser at 8:31. 11:29 Remaining. |
| 2nd Period |
| NY Islanders Goal - Lubomir Visnovsky, from Casey Cizikas and Colin McDonald at 6:22. 13:38 Remaining. |
| Toronto Goal - Nazem Kadri (7), from Mark Fraser and Cody Franson at 8:55. 11:05 Remaining. |
| Toronto Goal - James van Riemsdyk (12), from David Steckel and Colton Orr at 10:25. 9:35 Remaining. |
| Toronto Goal - Nazem Kadri (8), from Mike Kostka and Carl Gunnarsson at 14:12. 5:48 Remaining. |
| 3rd Period |
| NY Islanders Goal - Andrew MacDonald, from Kyle Okposo and Mark Streit at 5:31. 14:29 Remaining. |
| NY Islanders Goal - Kyle Okposo (2), unassisted at 10:08. 9:52 Remaining. |
| Overtime |
| Toronto Goal - Dion Phaneuf (4), from Mikhail Grabovski and Clarke MacArthur at 1:11. 3:49 Remaining. |
