| 1st Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 6:40 | Buffalo | Buffalo Goal - Tyler Ennis (6), from Drew Stafford at 13:20. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| 15:08 | Toronto | Mike Brown - 2 minutes for roughing |
| 19:18 | Buffalo | Alexander Sulzer - 2 minutes for holding |
| |
| 2nd Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 18:45 | Toronto | Toronto Power-Play Goal - Dion Phaneuf (3), from Phil Kessel and Cody Franson at 1:15. |
| 1:56 | Toronto | Toronto Goal - James van Riemsdyk (10), from Phil Kessel and Mike Kostka at 18:04. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| 3:38 | Buffalo | Nathan Gerbe - 2 minutes for tripping |
| 7:08 | Buffalo | Kevin Porter - 2 minutes for interference on goalkeeper |
| 12:55 | Toronto | Bench - 2 minutes for too many men/ice - bench served by Clarke MacArthur |
| |
| 3rd Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 5:32 | Toronto | Toronto Power-Play Goal - James van Riemsdyk (11), from Cody Franson and Dion Phaneuf at 14:28. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| 3:07 | Toronto | Frazer McLaren - 5 minutes for fighting (maj) |
| 3:07 | Buffalo | John Scott - 5 minutes for fighting (maj) |
| 4:14 | Toronto | Dion Phaneuf - 2 minutes for roughing |
| 4:14 | Buffalo | Nathan Gerbe - 2 minutes for roughing |
| 12:36 | Buffalo | Kevin Porter - 2 minutes for tripping |
| 13:20 | Buffalo | Jochen Hecht - 2 minutes for delaying game-puck over glass |
| 16:00 | Toronto | Leo Komarov - 2 minutes for holding |
