| 1st Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 2:11 | NY Rangers | NY Rangers Goal - Brad Richards (18), from Carl Hagelin and Michael Del Zotto at 17:49. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| No Penalties |
| |
| 2nd Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 14:34 | Columbus | Columbus Power-Play Goal - Derick Brassard (11), from Antoine Vermette at 5:26. |
| 6:47 | NY Rangers | NY Rangers Goal - Artem Anisimov (11), from Dan Girardi and John Mitchell at 13:13. |
| No Penalties |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| 1:26 | NY Rangers | Carl Hagelin - 2 minutes for hooking |
| 5:21 | NY Rangers | Marian Gaborik - 2 minutes for hi-sticking |
| 9:31 | Columbus | Derek Dorsett - 2 minutes for interference |
| 9:59 | Columbus | Rick Nash - 2 minutes for hooking |
| 17:41 | NY Rangers | Steve Eminger - 2 minutes for holding |
| |
| 3rd Period Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 1:33 | Columbus | Columbus Goal - Rick Nash (19), from Jeff Carter and R.J. Umberger at 18:27. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
| 12:17 | NY Rangers | Anton Stralman - 2 minutes for delaying game-puck over glass |
| |
| Overtime Summary |
| Time left | Team | Scoring Detail |
| 4:38 | NY Rangers | NY Rangers Goal - Derek Stepan (12), from Michael Del Zotto and Marian Gaborik at :22. |
| Time | Team | Penalty Detail |
